Galloo Island Light Station in 1911. Archival photo, public domain.
By Watertown Post Staff
HOUNSFIELD, New York. A conservation easement held by the Thousand Islands Land Trust permanently protects 1,410 acres of Galloo Island, about 70 percent of the roughly 2,000-acre island off the Jefferson County shore. The Great Lakes Commission’s November 13 news digest called it the largest project by acreage in the land trust’s history and reported that the protection includes about five miles of shoreline.
Galloo sits in the eastern end of Lake America, offshore from the Henderson area and southwest of Sackets Harbor. Its shore and coastal wetlands give migrating waterfowl a place to stop, rest and feed. The Land Trust Alliance also notes that monarch butterflies use the island as a stopover. Protecting land here keeps habitat intact on an island where the next patch of shoreline is a flight away.
The agreement limits what can be done on the protected land. An easement does not, by itself, turn private property into a public park. The state already manages two separate parcels on Galloo, including the lighthouse and former Coast Guard station sites, as part of its Lake Ontario Islands Wildlife Management Area. Little Galloo and Gull Island are also part of that state management area, with seasonal restrictions to protect nesting birds. That is separate from the new Galloo easement.
The island has a farming history as well as a maritime one. An archaeological study records that Ontario Stock Farms had acquired most of Galloo by 1923 to raise sheep and other animals. The island’s own history also records that Charles and Jan Fitzpatrick farmed there for years in the mid-20th century. Local maritime histories describe shallow-draft scows that carried sheep and cattle among the islands. Hans Wilder, the Watertown Post’s digital editor, grew up in Sackets Harbor and remembers a little boat making trips from the village to the nearby islands in the 1970s. He recalls sheep being carried. “I can’t remember the name of the boat. I was a kid,” Wilder said.
There is a name in the federal records worth checking. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’ 1968 Great Lakes vessel directory lists Charles W. Fitzpatrick’s H. B. Kishman, a 39-foot steel boat, and records his freight service between Sackets Harbor and Galloo Island. That makes it a candidate for the boat Wilder remembers. The directory does not say it carried sheep.
The island’s first light station dates to 1820, and the U.S. Coast Guard says the present tower was first lit in 1867. At the other end of Galloo, the former Coast Guard station at Gill Harbor closed in 1973. The lighthouse and boathouse are reminders of how people once lived and worked here. The new easement protects a different kind of traffic: the birds and butterflies that still stop on their way across the lake.