Opinion by Hans Wilder | The Watertown Post
Night fell over the North Country. A thin wind came off the river. Somewhere in the dark a man discovered that the Watertown Post still stood behind Anthony Constantino, and by morning we had been declared a fictional news organization, annexed to Kentucky, and informed that the congressman-elect would be out of a job before Christmas. This was a remarkable amount of reconnaissance for a party that never made it past the comment box.
“Upstate Kentucky. NY-21 is a joke,” announced one cartographer. We thank him for redrawing the frontier without troubling either state legislature. Another wrote, “This is not an actual news organization.” He then left that dispatch beneath an actual article on the actual Facebook page of the news organization he had just abolished. The ghost of our newsroom thanks him for stopping by.
Then came the fellow who sent six laughing faces without a word. Six. Not five, which would have been frivolous. Six, which apparently constitutes a finding of fact. A thumbs-down and a circus tent arrived a little farther down the thread. By then I was beginning to wonder whether I’d opened Facebook or taken a wrong turn into the midway at the Jefferson County Fair.
My favorite was the bus. One reader noted that nearly 7,000 ballots were blank in the House race. Fair enough: New York’s unofficial tally shows 6,839. Then he supposed those blanks mostly belonged to Republicans who couldn’t bring themselves to cross party lines, and sent a bus over a cliff to illustrate the point. The number was real. The passengers were his invention. A blank ballot doesn’t tell you who left it blank, what party they belong to, or why they did it. You can drive the bus anywhere you like once you’ve invented everybody aboard.
There was a fair question in the thicket: What will Constantino actually do for NY-21? That’s precisely what we intend to ask him. One reader put it more plainly than most: “Time will tell.” It will. Our readers have roads to get to work on, farms to keep running and neighbors stationed at Fort Drum. They deserve more from their congressman than a good fight on Facebook, and they deserve more from us than applause when he gets something right.
There’s another bit of arithmetic that won’t please the Republican clubhouse. In Siena’s pre-election poll, 21 percent of Republican likely voters said they intended to vote for Democrat Blake Gendebien. Ten percent of Democratic likely voters said they intended to vote for Constantino. That’s an 11-point gap in the poll, not a head count from Election Day. The secret ballot keeps that tally to itself. But if you were among the Republicans who told Siena you’d rather send the Democrat to Washington, take a good look in the mirror. You ought to be ashamed of what you were prepared to help do. The state’s unofficial count put Constantino ahead by 4,231 votes. That’s a narrow enough trail that nobody ought to swagger about how the outcome was never in doubt.
And here’s my quarrel with the Republicans in name only. If you want to make a habit of working against the Republican ticket while keeping the party title for the good china and the seat at the head of the table, have the decency to resign from the party. You ought to be ashamed of asking Republicans for their trust while treating your own label like a coat you can take off whenever the room gets warm. We don’t need that kind of loyalty. An honest Democrat who tells you where he stands is easier to deal with than a Republican who makes you check which door he came in through.
The Watertown Post stands with President Donald Trump, Congressman-elect Anthony Constantino in NY-21, and Congresswoman Claudia Tenney in NY-24. We said so in daylight and we’ll say it after dark. We’ll also ask them hard questions. If they have to read a little farther down the page to find those questions, they can take heart: at least we didn’t make them count six laughing faces first.