A North Country Look at Gas, Groceries and the 2026 Vote
By Misté Morales | The Ripple Effect | November 20, 2026
The day before the election, twelve gallons of gas cost about $52 in the Watertown area. That was after the price had gone down. On the corresponding Monday a year earlier, those same twelve gallons cost about $37. A driver who heard that gas was getting cheaper and still wondered where the grocery money went had good reason to feel that way. Fifteen dollars that could have gone toward dinner went into the tank. www.aol.com
Here in the North Country, one explanation keeps coming up for why Republicans lost Congress. People are worried about gas and groceries. I think there is a reason those two expenses get mentioned together. A family can put off buying a new couch. It has far less room to put off getting to work or feeding everybody until Friday. When a candidate promises to bring down the cost of living, people have a way to check on that promise every week.
This November, Democrats won control of the U.S. House and Senate. Republicans held New York’s 21st Congressional District, but a seat Elise Stefanik had won by 24 points in 2024 came within two points of changing hands. What happened here offers a way into the larger question of why Republicans lost Congress. And here is a question worth asking in a district that stayed red. What can Republicans learn even from a race they won? www.ap.org
What gas and groceries meant in New York
AAA put the Watertown-area average at $4.37 per gallon on November 2, down six cents in a week. A year earlier, the local average was $3.11. For someone buying twelve gallons to get to work, the two figures answer different questions. A six-cent drop saves 72 cents on twelve gallons. The year-over-year increase costs $15.12 on that same purchase. Over the course of four such purchases, the year-over-year difference comes to more than $60. That is enough to change what goes into the grocery cart. www.aol.com
Siena Research Institute asked 808 New York residents about household costs in a survey conducted from September 1 to October 3. Statewide, 77% said grocery prices were having a somewhat or very serious impact on their finances. Sixty-four percent said the same about gasoline. Among upstate respondents, the figures were 77% for groceries and 66% for gas. For many New Yorkers, those expenses were already serious concerns a month before the votes were counted. sri.siena.edu
The two trends had different histories. A year earlier, 79% of New Yorkers surveyed had already said groceries were straining their finances. Concern about gasoline, meanwhile, rose from 46% to 64% over that year. Going into the election, households were absorbing a much more widely felt fuel expense on top of a grocery bill that had been difficult for some time. sri.siena.edu
Anyone who shops the sales knows how differently a price change can land from one aisle to the next. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that October grocery prices across the Northeast rose 0.6% from September. Fruit and vegetable prices rose 1.9%, while cereals and bakery products fell 0.4%. For a North Country family deciding whether to drive to another store for cheaper produce, the price posted outside the gas station is part of the price of those groceries, too. www.bls.gov
What voters held Washington responsible for
Donald Trump ran for president promising to bring prices down. By this November, about two-thirds of voters nationwide told the AP Voter Poll that they believed his policies had made the economy worse. Among voters who held that view, roughly eight in ten said they voted for the Democratic candidate for the House. People had formed a judgment about how the president was handling the economy, and Republican candidates farther down the ballot had to answer for it. www.ap.org
The Senate result shows how far that dissatisfaction reached. Democrat James Talarico won in Texas. Among Texas voters who said inflation had caused their families severe hardship, about three-quarters backed him, according to AP. He also won a majority among Texans who described that hardship as moderate. A household could still be paying its bills and consider the squeeze serious enough to matter on Election Day. www.ap.org
Voters also had concerns about how Washington was being run. Roughly seven in ten people in the national AP poll said Congress was doing too little to check the president, including about four in ten Republicans. And about one in five who voted for a Democratic candidate held an unfavorable view of the Democratic Party itself. Some Americans were willing to give a candidate their vote while withholding their endorsement of the party behind that candidate. That distinction matters for Democrats trying to understand what they won as much as it does for Republicans trying to understand what they lost. www.ap.org
The scale of the change became clearer on November 17, when AP called Alaska’s Senate race for Democrat Mary Peltola. It was the ninth Republican-held Senate seat to flip, giving Democrats an incoming 56–44 majority. The last time Democrats gained at least nine Senate seats in a midterm was 1958, when Dwight Eisenhower was president. Midterms can be tough on the party in the White House. A Senate gain of this size is unusual even by that standard. apnews.com
One district, two Republican margins
In September, Quinnipiac University asked likely New York voters to name the most important issue in deciding their vote for governor. Cost of living came first among Democrats, Republicans and independents. Among those who picked it, Governor Kathy Hochul led Republican Bruce Blakeman 66% to 30%. Hochul went on to win statewide. Closer to home, North Country Public Radio’s Emily Russell reported seeing signs calling for Hochul’s removal and hearing similar sentiments from people at the polls. The governor’s winning coalition looked very different depending on which roads you drove.
A Times Union analysis of state and local returns found that Blakeman carried the territory within the 21st Congressional District by 23 percentage points. On the same ballot, Republican Anthony Constantino defeated Democrat Blake Gendebien for the open House seat by fewer than two. Comparing an incumbent in a presidential election with a newcomer in a midterm can take you only so far. These two Republicans, however, stood before the same district on the same November day.
Look at St. Lawrence County, where Gendebien is a dairy farmer from Lisbon. In the county’s unofficial November 4 report, with all 70 election districts reporting, roughly 62% backed Blakeman for governor across his three ballot lines. About 53% supported Gendebien for Congress. Farther south, Constantino drew some of his strongest support in the Mohawk Valley. Someone following the count in Canton could watch a Democrat carry the county for Congress and a Republican win the district seat. Both were accurate readings of the same election.
Some of that distinction was visible before Election Day. Siena and its media partners asked 496 likely voters in the 21st District which party they wanted to control Congress. Republicans led Democrats 50% to 45%. Then pollsters asked who would do a better job making prices more affordable. On that question, Gendebien led Constantino 49% to 40%. The district leaned Republican on control of the House, yet more of those surveyed trusted the Democrat on the very issue many families were talking about. sri.siena.edu
Other questions in the district poll help explain why the choice could be complicated. Gendebien led on support for farmers and small businesses and on relations with Canada. Constantino led on handling undocumented immigration. For a dairy community near an international border, all three subjects belong in a conversation about the local economy. And when North Country Public Radio reporters spoke with voters, some residents connected the strain of electric bills and other living costs to leadership in Albany. The same household could have a complaint for its governor and another for its president. sri.siena.edu
How many votes did the cost of living move in this particular race? That remains an open question. What stands out is that affordability gave a Democrat an opening in a district where Republicans had every reason to expect a much more comfortable win. Constantino will represent the farmers, business owners and families who preferred his opponent on prices, along with those who supported him. How he responds to their concerns will matter long after the margin of victory is forgotten.
My opinion on what Republicans can learn
I don’t believe this election was stolen. In my opinion, Republicans lost ground because they failed to make their long-term approach to the country’s recovery clear to the people they were asking to support it. They also needed to balance that approach with actions they could take right away. People deserved to see how their immediate needs were being met while the longer-term work was underway.
Take manufacturing as an example. The 2025 federal tax law allows businesses to deduct up to the full qualifying cost of certain U.S. production property when it goes into service. A business owner considering where to build a factory can see why that matters. A parent already working full time has a different question. Could that decision eventually mean a job close enough for my son or daughter to stay here? A date for apprenticeships to open or a list of trades the project expects to hire would give that family something to plan around. If the public is being asked to invest years of patience in an idea, I think those are fair questions to answer along the way. www.irs.gov
There were near-term actions to explain as well. In March, the Environmental Protection Agency announced a temporary waiver allowing the nationwide sale of gasoline blended with 15% ethanol beginning May 1. Its stated aim was to keep more fuel available ahead of summer. For someone in Northern New York, the practical questions are whether a station within driving distance offered it and whether buying it there made the commute any cheaper. Answering those questions would tell a family what a decision made in Washington actually did for them. It would also tell officials where their approach still needed work. www.epa.gov
To me, this goes deeper than explaining a policy better. A family can understand the reasoning behind a recovery plan perfectly well and still need help this month. If one part of the plan takes five years, what can be done in the first five weeks? If an existing measure is supposed to bring relief, who is responsible for checking whether it reached the people paying the bills? I would have liked to hear Republicans answer those questions with the same attention they gave to what they hoped the country would look like years from now.
Suppose a new plant opens here in five years and offers good jobs. The family that wants to be here when those jobs arrive has to be able to afford to stay for the next five winters. A long-term recovery plan ought to account for that family during construction as well as on opening day. I think Republicans underestimated how much it matters for citizens to see both things happening at once. Be clear about what will take time. Give people something tangible to judge in the meantime. And if the first step falls short, tell the public what you learned and what you’re changing. That is a conversation I believe Americans are perfectly capable of having.
Democrats will have their turn to answer for what Congress does next. Republicans who kept their seats, including here in the North Country, have that responsibility too. By the time the next election comes around, most of us will have forgotten the exact margin in the 21st District. We’ll still know what it costs to drive to work, feed the family and get through the week. The test for anyone promising an economic recovery is whether, after we fill the tank and buy the groceries, there’s a little more left.