This conceptual image illustrates one possible future for the former JB Wise property in downtown Watertown following demolition of the deteriorated structure. The rendering envisions a modern mixed-use development featuring commercial space, outdoor seating, landscaping, and pedestrian-friendly public areas. While taxpayers may be frustrated by the costs associated with the demolition, the cleared site presents an opportunity for redevelopment and investment in one of downtown Watertown's most visible locations. The neighboring Empsall's building would also benefit from enhanced waterfront views and improved surroundings.
-Watertown NY By Hans Wilder
For weeks, the conversation surrounding the demolition of the old JB Wise building has centered on one thing: the cost.
And make no mistake, taxpayers have every right to be frustrated. City officials have acknowledged that hundreds of thousands of dollars may be spent tearing down the building, with little chance of recovering the money from the owner.
But let’s take a moment and look at the other side of the ledger.
That building was finished.
Done.
The roof was failing, officials feared collapse, and demolition crews were eventually called in to remove what had become a growing safety concern.
Now, for the first time in decades, that section of downtown has a clean slate.
Instead of staring at a deteriorating structure that had long outlived its usefulness, residents can begin imagining what comes next. A modern mixed-use building. Outdoor dining. Apartments overlooking the Black River. A public plaza. New businesses. New jobs. New tax revenue.
The view has already changed.
If you’re sitting in the neighboring Empsall’s building, chances are your waterfront views just got a whole lot better. What was once a crumbling obstacle is now open sky.
Sometimes progress isn’t about preserving what exists. Sometimes progress is recognizing when something has reached the end of its life and making room for something better.
Watertown has done this before. Public Square itself has gone through cycles of decline and renewal over the generations, with old structures making way for new investment and redevelopment.
The real question isn’t whether the old JB Wise building should have come down.
The real question is what we put there next.
If city leaders, developers, and property owners get this right, nobody will be talking about the demolition bill ten years from now.
They’ll be talking about the project that transformed an empty lot into one of the most attractive pieces of real estate in downtown Watertown.
The rubble will be gone.
The opportunity will remain.
About the Author
